DIY RP-524 ($99–$129) vs. Contingency Firms (25%–50%)
Most Westchester homeowners overpay for property tax appeals because the municipal math is opaque—not because the filing is legally complex. Filing Form RP-524 yourself costs nothing at the town clerk; a $99–$129 software packet handles the RAR calculation, comp grid, and form population.
Expect a BAR Denial — Plan for SCAR
Local Boards of Assessment Review across Westchester routinely deny 70%–90% of initial residential grievances without an appraisal. That applies whether you file yourself or hire a 50% firm. Most reductions happen in September at Small Claims Assessment Review (SCAR) ($30 NY court fee), which requires a timely June RP-524 filing first.
Which Option Makes Sense?
- DIY ($99 / $129): Best if your expected savings is over $1,000/yr and you're fine signing and submitting a 4-page form (plus a 1-page SCAR petition in September if denied).
- Contingency representative (25%–50%): Best if your case is borderline or you prefer someone to attend a SCAR hearing for you under NY RPTL § 730(6).